How to get the best insurance deal
A practical checklist for paying less without losing cover — comparing properly, avoiding auto-renewal traps, setting your excess, and being accurate.
On this page
Cheaper insurance isn’t about one clever trick — it’s a short routine you run at each renewal. Here’s the checklist.
The checklist
- 1Compare like-for-likeSame cover level and excess. Check more than one comparison site — none covers the whole market — plus any big insurer that isn’t listed.
- 2Never just auto-renewRead the renewal notice (it shows last year’s price next to this year’s) and treat it as negotiable.
- 3Set a sensible excessA higher voluntary excess cuts the premium — but only pick an amount you could afford to pay if you claimed tomorrow.
- 4Pay annually if you canMonthly payments usually add interest. Paying once a year is typically cheaper overall.
- 5Drop add-ons you don’t needKey cover, courtesy car, legal cover — useful for some, wasted for others. Don’t pay for cover you already have elsewhere.
In short
Compare like-for-like across several sources, don’t auto-renew blindly, set a voluntary excess you could afford, pay annually to avoid interest, and cut add-ons you don’t need — all while giving completely accurate information, because a detail fudged to save money can cost you the whole claim.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to pay for insurance annually or monthly?
Paying annually is usually cheaper, because paying monthly is effectively borrowing — insurers often add interest to spread the cost. If you can afford the annual premium, it typically saves money over the year.
Can giving wrong details to lower the price backfire?
Yes — badly. Deliberately or carelessly giving inaccurate information (‘fronting’ on a car policy, understating value, wrong address) can void the policy or see a claim refused. Always be accurate; the small saving isn’t worth it.
Do comparison sites show every insurer?
No single comparison site covers the whole market, and some big insurers aren’t on them at all. Check more than one site, and get a direct quote from any insurer that isn’t listed.
Sources & last checked
- How to cut your insurance costs — MoneyHelper (Money & Pensions Service)
- General insurance pricing rules — Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)
Last checked against official sources: 9 July 2026.